Dr. Baldy,
Very interesting thoughts! Thank you for putting time and effort into researching and explaining this view!
I would like to share my thoughts on the subject.
I completely agree that there is much in place with the ENPI and that many events that need to be in place have come to fruition. I will still remember this ENPI until the day I die, if nothing comes of it, because it will be on of the most anomalous things in my entire life experience. How could a ten nation alliance in Europe come, just like the prophets and fathers said would come? Then a leader comes after them, and wrestles with 3 of them for influence, and being successful in that endeavor. Then making a seven year covenant with Israel, just like the prophet Daniel, and Irenaeus and Hyppolytus and others around the world agree.
How could God let this happen, and it not be it?? Why would God do this to us, if now is not the time??? I don't know, but there is still time for this ENPI.
I appreciate very much, Mr. Baldy, your willingness to counter deep-seated assumptions that have been made in the prophetic world, which cause people to overlook events that should be paid deep attention to and are likely the fulfillments of prophecy, that have no excuse to at least be watched. I am very grateful of your willingness to stand up in debate on this board, and open the ENPI up to criticism, even when it has issues that, at the surface, cause the human mind to doubt, even though they are not outside of God's power.
Nonetheless, as difficult as it would be for me to give up the ENPI, I struggle, theologically, with the idea that, with the information we have presented in the Bible, that we can reasonably have an abomination of desolation after the end of the 70th week, or much after July 20th. Allow me to explain. (Also, forgive me if I have in any way misrepresented your position, Mr. Baldy.)
By the termination of the 70 weeks, and, by definition, the termination of the 70th week itself, the following conditions must be met, as you mentioned.
Daniel 9:24 NASB
24"Seventy (A)weeks have been decreed for your people and your holy city, to finish the transgression, to make an end of sin, to (B)make atonement for iniquity, to bring in (C)everlasting righteousness, to seal up vision and prophecy and to anoint the most holy place.
Specifically for the Jews and Jerusalem, 70 weeks are decreed to:
1. To finish the transgression
2. To make an end of sin
3. To make atonement for iniquity
4. To bring in everlasting righteousness
5. To seal up vision and prophecy
6. To anoint the most holy place
Concerning the last week, we are given information:
Daniel 9:27 NASB
27"And he will make a firm covenant with the many for one week, but in the middle of the week he will put a stop to sacrifice and grain offering; and on the wing of (A)abominations will come one who makes desolate, even until a (B)complete destruction, one that is decreed, is poured out on the one who makes desolate."
Daniel 9:27 ESV
27And he shall make a strong covenant with many for one week,[a] and for half of the week he shall put an end to sacrifice and offering.(A) And on the wing of abominations shall come one who makes desolate, until(B) the decreed end is poured out on the desolator."
It says someone will make a firm covenant for seven years. But for half of those aforementioned seven years he will cause sacrifice and offering to be put to an end. And also, someone will make desolate until he is destroyed (by many people's interpretation, the same person who makes the covenant).
According to our theory, the European Neighborhood and Partnership Instrument is the confirmation of the covenant for 1 week mentioned above. This means that the 7-year covenant itself seems to determine the parameters of the final week.
So, in our case, the 70th week began on 1 January 2007 and terminates on 31 December 2013.
We could argue that God has a different timetable than man's and that his 70th week merely loosely corresponds with man's covenant, but this is hard to justify in my opinion, especially since it is too late for the 70th week to operate on a Jewish calendar, and because the passage itself seems to define the last week as defined by the duration of the covenant, and because it seems there is no other 7 year period for which we could say is "God's last week" other than the period of time provided by the ENPI itself.
So, in summary, the
70th week is 1 January 2007 ----> 31 December 2013 because:
1) The covenant duration defines the last week, according to the above verse.
2) The ENPI is decreed from 1 January 2007 until 31 December 2013.
3) It is too late for the 70th week to operate on a Jewish calendar. (i.e. only lasting 7 Jewish years)
4) There is no other 7 year time frame that could be "God's week" vs. man's, that I am aware of, other than what is provided by the ENPI duration itself.
Given this, 1 January 2007-->31 December 2013 duration is the 70th week itself, if the ENPI is the covenant.
By the end of the 70 weeks, according to Daniel 9:24, the following must be accomplished for the Jews and Jerusalem:
1. To finish the transgression
2. To make an end of sin
3. To make atonement for iniquity
4. To bring in everlasting righteousness
5. To seal up vision and prophecy
6. To anoint the most holy place
(Note this is decreed for "your people" and "your holy city." It does not necessarily, and probably does not apply, to the world at large. For example, at the 7th trumpet, Christ seems to establish his earthly kingdom, but the Antichrist is not completely eradicated until the end of the bowl judgments and Armageddon.)
Therefore since 1 January 2007 --> 31 December 2013 is the last week, all of the above things must be accomplished by the end of 31 December 2013 as well.
We also are aware of certain end time events that take place for a specified period of time:
A.2"Leave out the (C)court which is outside the temple and do not measure it, for (D)it has been given to the nations; and they will (E)tread under foot (F)the holy city for (G)forty-two months. (Revelation 11:2)
B.3"And I will grant authority to my two (H)witnesses, and they will prophesy for (I)twelve hundred and sixty days, clothed in (J)sackcloth." (Revelation 11:3)
C.6Then the woman fled into the wilderness where she had a place prepared by God, so that there she would be nourished for (BS)one thousand two hundred and sixty days. (Revelation 12:6)
D.5There was given to him a mouth (DN)speaking arrogant words and blasphemies, and authority to act for (DO)forty-two months was given to him.(Revelation 13:5)
In summary:
A. The nations trample Jerusalem for 42 months.
B. The two witnesses prophesy 1260 days
C. Israelites protected in the desert for 1260 days
D. The beast has authority for 42 months.
I am going to speak in a very straightforward way, just for sake of clarity of my position. It is by no means meant to be taken undiplomatically, nor is it meant to sound in any way unfriendly or unkind. This is just for clarity's sake.
I struggle with the idea that any of these time periods of 42 months/1260 days, can exceed the end of the 70th week (in our case, 31 December 2013) for the following reasons:
1)It is hard to say that transgression and sin are brought to an end, and everlasting righteousness is brought in for Jerusalem, when the two witnesses lay dead in the streets of Jerusalem after the 1260 days and are gloated over by the world.
2) Also, they lay in the street before the 7th trumpet, when it is said that God's kingdom becomes terrestrial. The whole period of 1260 days happens before this event.
3) It is hard to say that transgression and sin are brought to an end in Jerusalem, and everlasting righteousness is brought in for Jerusalem, if the Gentiles are trampling the city for 42 months.
4) It is hard in my opinion, to say that sin and transgression are brought to an end for Jerusalem, and everlasting righteousness is in place in Jerusalem, when the Jews are not even in Jerusalem, but are nourished for 1260 days in the desert.
5) It is hard to say, in my opinion, to say that sin and transgression are brought in, and everlasting righteousness brought in for the city, when the beast has authority for 42 months and Christ has not yet established any kind of authority on earth (7th trumpet). Also, since the AOD happens in Israel and Jerusalem, this also applies for why the AOD cannot happen after 31 December 2013.
As far as the 1290 days and the 1335 days, here is my view:
I realize that any estimations regarding these numbers cannot be totally certain. Nevertheless, there are some things that I would have difficulty with it.
Daniel 12:11 ESV
11And from the time that(A) the regular burnt offering is taken away and(B) the abomination that makes desolate is set up, there shall be 1,290 days.
It is said that from the time of the sacrifice being taken away and the AOD is set up, there will be 1290 days. It does not seem to say to me from the time sacrifice is abolished
until the AOD, there will be 1290 days. It says "and" tying the two events together when linking them to the number 1290 days, and using the word "from" indicating that those events start the 1290 days.
The 1,335 days could apply to the Millenium, and those who pass the sheep and goat judgment and are not destroyed by Christ before the kingdom.
One possible explanation of the disparity between the 42 months/1260 days of Revelation and the 1290 days of Daniel 12:11 is what is included in the time frame of Daniel vs. Revelation. Daniel includes the defeat of the Antichrist in the discussion. However, the 42 months of Revelation do not include the defeat of the Antichrist in my opinion, because Christ seems to establish his throne on earth shortly after the 42 months/1260 days of Revelation 11 and the two witnesses are over. However, all throughout the bowl judgments after Christ has established his thrown at the 7th trumpet, the beast still has political authority and is not completely defeated until Armageddon. So basically, Revelation's 42 months describes when the beast has full sway, while Daniel includes the whole tenure of Antichrist, including the time before and up until his defeat.
So in summary, if the 70th week ends 31 December 2013, then all 6 criteria of the 70 weeks must be completed.
Again, I immensely appreciate all the work you have done Mr Baldy, defending and researching this theory, and exposing pre-conceived notions. However, I just personally struggle with any AOD, beast rule, or Gentile trampling of Jerusalem, later than July 21, because then they don't have enough time before the end of the 70th week to complete the allotted tasks for the appropriate amount of time, because once the 70th week ends, certain events don't seem to be compatible with the termination of the 70 weeks.
Now if the AOD happens in September, for example, totally flying in the face of my expectations, then I will accept it. Like you said, things often have happened contrary to our expectations. That is why it is important for us all to be watchful for anything at all times. Even the prewrath.com website readily admits we could be in th 70th week and completely not realize it. They could have made another 7 year covenant 2 years ago and we missed it. (I am hypothetically speaking). However, it in my opinion, the ENPI supplies so many theological problems for an AOD after the month of July, that the theory can't really be advocated any more, or hold up to theological scrutiny. (Not to say that we can't at least keep periodic tabs on it just for security purposes, but it seems to have been significantly defeated by the end of July at least, but more likely around the 21st or 22nd.
These are just my thoughts and I could be wrong, as I have in the past. I just wanted to share with you my thoughts, and I very much mean the entirety of this message to be taken in a friendly and diplomatic manner. If for some reason I poorly worded something that seems to come off wrong, please forgive me.
Thanks,
Eschologizer
"for they themselves report what kind of reception you gave us. They tell how you turned to God from idols to serve the living and true God, and to wait for his Son from heaven, whom he raised from the dead—Jesus, who rescues us from the coming wrath." 1 Thessalonians 1:9-10